The vocation of the person is to construct his own solitude as a conditio sine qua non for a valid encounter with other persons, for intelligent cooperation and for communion in love. – Merton, Disputed Questions, X.
I wrote this piece a couple of years ago and posted it to another blog. I thought I would repost here simply because it is an issue getting a little traction lately. -lp
I have to confess that I don’t think that we “do” Lenten fasting well in my neck of American Christianity. Most often people give up some token item for the fast, which really isn’t a fast at all. Giving up chocolate or soda (soda is my big weakness) is nice and all, but doesn’t really amount to the sort of disciplined fasting that the church really expected through the years. Western Christians – especially Roman Catholics – take their cues from Pope Paul VI’s “Apostolic Constitution on Penance,” which reorganized fasting and abstinence observations into their current form. This includes a fast is one full meal per day plus smaller portion of food at another time of the day that does not equal a full meal. Abstinence means one cannot eat meat (ie flesh), but are permitted eggs and dairy, and even to use sauces which are seasoned with meat but in which meat is not the lion’s share of the meal (ie chicken broth and the like).
Fasting is to be practiced by all people 18 to 59 on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday, and abstinence is to be practiced on Ash Wednesday, Good Friday, and all Fridays during Lent.
In the Eastern Orthodox Church, fasting is quite a bit more strict and carries on beyond the Lenten season. The Orthodox Church in America describes fasting as, “an essential element of the Christian Life. Christ fasted and taught men to fast. Blessed fasting is done in secret, without ostentation or accusation of others (Mt 6:16; Rom 14). It has as its goal the purification of our lives, the liberation of our souls and bodies from sin, the strengthening of our human powers of love for God and man, the enlightening of our entire being for communion with the Blessed Trinity.” The Lenten fast is as appears below:
Week before Lent (“Cheesefare Week”): Meat and other animal products are prohibited, but eggs and dairy products are permitted, even on Wednesday and Friday.
First Week of Lent: Only two full meals are eaten during the first five days, on Wednesday and Friday after the Presanctified Liturgy. Nothing is eaten from Monday morning until Wednesday evening, the longest time without food in the Church year. (Few laymen keep these rules in their fullness). For the Wednesday and Friday meals, as for all weekdays in Lent, meat and animal products, fish, dairy products, wine and oil are avoided. On Saturday of the first week, the usual rule for Lenten Saturdays begins (see below).
Weekdays in the Second through Sixth Weeks: The strict fasting rule is kept every day: avoidance of meat, meat products, fish, eggs, dairy, wine and oil.
Saturdays and Sundays in the Second through Sixth Weeks: Wine and oil are permitted; otherwise the strict fasting rule is kept.
Holy Week: The Thursday evening meal is ideally the last meal taken until Pascha. At this meal, wine and oil are permitted. The Fast of Great and Holy Friday is the strictest fast day of the year: even those who have not kept a strict Lenten fast are strongly urged not to eat on this day. After St. Basil’s Liturgy on Holy Saturday, a little wine and fruit may be taken for sustenance. The fast is sometimes broken on Saturday night after Resurrection Matins, or, at the latest, after the Divine Liturgy on Pascha.
Wine and oil are permitted on several feast days if they fall on a weekday during Lent. Consult your parish calendar. On Annunciation and Palm Sunday, fish is also permitted.
I used to fast every year during Lent. Often that fast was a combination of the Roman Catholic rules and of giving up something. One year I used the Lenten fast to quit smoking. Several years – even during my wilder college days – I chose to give up alcohol. I used to look forward to abstention from alcohol in those days because I felt my head was always clearer and it gave me a chance to focus on the close of the semester. I often wouldn’t eat meat at all during Lent, though I usually simply abstained on Fridays. In fact, after one Lent I didn’t eat meat again for more than two years.
I have not fasted from food in six years. It isn’t because I am lazy or because I am weak. But fasting from food cannot and probably will not ever again be a part of Lent for me. Why? I am married to an adult anorexic. Though she mostly enjoys healthy times, she has struggled with symptoms for decades, and must be conscious to this day about food intake and her anxiety levels.
Anorexia is so much more complex than what you may have learned in that 80’s after school special you watched as a kid. It is often not about a person feeling like they are “too fat” and then starving himself or herself. The reasons people restrict their food intake are vast and diverse. For some it a response to stress or anxiety; for others it is a need to feel in control. For yet others it is a way of self-abuse, much in the same way that others may cut or burn their bodies in order to self-mutilate.
Anorexia is not just about teenage girls either. While most cases of anorexia develop in the teenage years and rarely develop after the age of twenty, it is estimated that at least 10% of all active anorexics are above the age of forty. It is also estimated that for 60-70% of all anorexics, anxiety disorders exist that are unrelated to body weight or body image. So anorexia is not about a person desiring to appear thin.
A key to not suffering a setback in the recovery process is to be mindful about food intake. Encouraging food restriction or participating in food restriction can often lead to anorexics suffering a relapse in symptoms. This is especially dangerous when it comes to religious fasting. When the church ties pleasing God or spiritual growth a restriction of food intake, it becomes a recipe for disaster. The church needs to find other more creative and caring ways to encourage those with eating disorders to participate more fully in the life of the church, especially during Lent.
“Most adult anorexics struggle with the shame aspect. When that shame is transferred onto your spirituality because you can’t participate in fasting – which is where we focus so much of our energy during Lent – it makes you feel even more ashamed, more broken. While that brokenness is a part of Lent, there is a point at which it becomes unhealthy,” one adult with anorexia told me.
In some ways this is a post with a beginning and a middle, but with no real end. There are no real conclusions that I have drawn or advice that I have to offer. To diagnose a problem is a good start, and we as the church must find ways to help those suffering with eating disorders observe a Lenten discipline without contributing to unhealthy food restriction and without making those with eating disorders feel even more on the outside during Lent. I sure wish I had some answers to how this works. Perhaps some readers do.
It is late, after midnight, and a nice steady rain is falling. I am pretty sure everyone else in the house is asleep, and I have to confess that I am enjoying the silence. It has been a very busy couple of weeks, with two funerals and many illnesses, both serious and minor. My two youngest had strep throat and it appears now that my lovely bride has contracted the flu. Basically what this means is no time off the past couple of weeks.
I think that what has made this difficult this time around has been a spiritual dry spell. Oddly enough, this dry spell has occurred in the midst of me being in a doctoral program in Christian Spirituality. Weird, huh?! Maybe not. I recall a couple of years ago when my wife was finishing her dissertation that she decided she no longer wanted to teach. I guess you study something enough that it sort of repels you. This becomes a little more problematic though when what you study is prayer and devotion.
My thesis is done. I need to send it in for a final format check, but all the content has been signed off on by my readers. And yet all this studying has left me in a place spiritually that seems…well…dry.
It makes me look forward to Lent this year in a personal way. It will be a good chance to put away academic study for a while and return to using my reading and study time for more personal, devotional use. This year I think I will spend the time studying John Cassian’s Institutes. Cassian was a student of one of my favorite early church monastics, Evagrius Ponticus. At the heart of the Institutes are reflections on what the early Christian writers called the passions. Nothing is quite so spiritually motivating as a Church Father to kick you in the head for six straight weeks. Hopefully this – along with more discipline around the daily office – will get me back in a groove again.
Inspired by friend and colleague Pastor David Hansen, I decided to post what a week in the life of a Pastor, Husband and Father looks like. No week is typical, and there are always variations in hours, locations and tasks. Part of the reason I love this vocation is that there is such little room for boredom. I like the variety.
Saturday, January 12:
Slept in a little this morning. Was awakened by my six year old daughter attempting to put lip gloss on my lab, who was also asleep with me. He didn’t care for the gloss…must have been the color. Got up, had an awesome breakfast of blueberry pancakes and bacon, and spent some time chatting with my wife over coffee. Then it was off to the home office. I usually spend four to five hours on Saturday mornings preparing for Sunday. On this particular day, I ended up re-writing much of my sermon. After lunch, I spent the afternoon knocking around the house, preparing for two house guests.
Sunday, January 13:
Woke up early, excited that Confirmation class would consist of watching the film Luther. After confirmation was worship. The re-written sermon should have been re-written again. I would say it was a single, maybe a double, but far from a home run. It was nice to see a couple of new families in worship today. Hopefully they’ll return. After church it was home for lunch, a nice nap, and then started getting ready for the week ahead while my wife prepared a fantastic dinner. Looked over some ideas for a council retreat, and spent some time praying about a facilitator and topic. Also spent a little time reading Gordon Lathrop’s book Pastor.
Monday, January 14:
I work from home on Mondays. After breakfast did 3.1 miles on the treadmill, my first 5k. I studied some in preparation for my sermon. I cleared up a billing issue with one of our vendors (I lost a check like a dope). Made several phone calls to check in folks. Spent time preparing for our monthly Men’s Prayer and Study group. Picked up kids from carpool, ate dinner, and then off to the church to lead the men’s group. Made it home around 9:30.
Tuesday, January 15:
Spent bulk of morning working with our email host trying to diagnose some issues with lost email accounts, lack of forwarding and such. Sent off my annual clergy report to the Bishop. Talked to a potential karate instructor about use of our facility. Looked over bulletins for the coming week. Filled out as much as possible of Forms A&C, which are statistical forms for the ELCA. Carpool, snack with kids, cooked dinner and laid low for the night. Read a little more Lathrop.
Wednesday, January 16:
Did a couple of miles on the treadmill. Bad weather made traffic awful, which is never fun when headed to do hospital visits. Cold, rainy, and no covered parking available when I arrived. Did get to make a visit to a member and minister to a family in the waiting area concerned about a loved one’s illness. Made it back to church in time grab a quick lunch and prepare for evening’s Bible study. Carpool, looked over notes prior to Bible study, then back to the church. Made it home around 9ish.
Thursday, January 17:
Brisk treadmill walk for 30 minutes of so. Lots of phone calls and emails this morning. Phone started ringing as soon as I got on treadmill. Researched Lenten sermon series. Submitted my annual report to the congregation. Met with a parishioner for counseling. Spent some time looking over pre-marital counseling materials I will be using with a couple in February. Carpool. Got home and played with my kids. Made a big pot of jambalaya. Spent the evening in.
Friday, January 18:
Pastor’s Sabbath! My four year old is at home on Fridays, so we have a blast together. After breakfast we played with Star Wars actions figures. Then we jumped in my recliner to watch Power Rangers. Then more Star Wars. I have my own lightsaber. I did some laundry in the midst of that and then we headed off to pick up my daughter. Gorgeous day outside, so we played outside with the neighbors until it was dark. I also finally took down the last of the Christmas lights. Yes, I am a slacker. Put the kids down and the wife and I ordered some take out and enjoyed the quiet.
Saturday, January 19
Much like last Saturday but no pancakes. Worked for a few hours, and then watched Pocahontas I and II with my daughter. (I mostly napped). Then it was all about focusing on Sunday again. They seem to keep coming.
Friday Punk Rock
When voters go to the polls this November to vote, they will be faced with decisions other than who will inhabit the White House. Of particular interest to many Georgians, myself included, is a constitutional amendment that will allow the state the ability to create public charter schools.
The measure on the ballot will read as follows:
Provides for improving student achievement and parental involvement through more public charter school options.
House Resolution No. 1162 Ga. L. 2012, p. 1364
Shall the Constitution of Georgia be amended to allow state or local approval of public charter schools upon the request of local communities?
After much deliberation I am opposed to passage of this amendment. At one time I was leaning toward supporting it, but that is no longer the case. Let me briefly state my case.
1. Amending the constitution is a big deal. It should only be done in extreme situations. In this case, it is being done to avoid having this issue be heard by the Georgia Supreme Court.
2. I think the ballot question is misleading. Who would vote against student achievement? The way it is written also suggests that a local approval program is not already in place. In fact, your local school board has the authority to authorize charter schools already.
3. Related to item #2, what this measure does is create a new state board, one whose members are appointed and not elected. This board of unelected officials can go into local communties and set up charter schools regardless of what the local community thinks about the issue. It takes power away from the local level and consolidates it in the hands of a few appointed officials. They will have the ability to usurp the decisions of local, elected school boards, thus short circuiting the democratic process.
4. Our own State Superintendent, Republican Dr. John Barge broke ranks with his party and said the following about this amendment: “I cannot support the creation of a new and costly state bureaucracy that takes away local control of schools and unnecessarily duplicates the good work already being done by local districts, the Georgia Department of Education, and the state Board of Education. What’s more, this constitutional amendment would direct taxpayer dollars into the pockets of out-of-state, for-profit charter school companies whose schools perform no better than traditional public schools and locally approved charter schools (and worse, in some cases).”
5. Related to #4. We are reaping the results of the poor quality of education offered by the many proprietary colleges that operate and get access to state and federal financial aid funds. If you have not seen it, I highly recommend the PBS Frontline episode College, Inc. Do we want to see this model duplicated at the K-12 level with the proliferation of for-profit schools?
6. Vote Smart Georgia reports that the cost to operate the unelected board alone will be in excess of $1 million a year.
7. If this passes, the state is going to magically create or find $430 million in additional revenue to fund these new charter schools in a time when we are furloughing teachers and moving to shortened school days/years because our public schools are already grossly underfunded.
Let me say this: I am not opposed to charter schools. They can be wonderful assets to communities. I would support the establishment of charter schools in my own county. Make no mistake, this amendment is not about charter schools, it is about taking power out of the hands of local communities and putting it in the hands of a few people removed from the local realities of individual districts. I cannot in good conscience support such a measure.
+ Today is August 14th, the Eve of the Dormition of the Theotokos (Assumption of Mary for the RCC folks). I am really saddened every year that this feast rolls around that Lutherans still haven’t figure out what to do with the Blessed Mother.
+ There has been quite a bit of upheaval in our home over the last few weeks. My wife started back to work after having the summer off, then the following week my daughter started Kindergarten. Yesterday my youngest started pre-K (and nearly ripped my heart from my chest). Next Monday, my oldest starts college. There is a real sense in which all of them are taking steps toward independence. While this makes me proud of them, it is also painful as you just want to hold them forever
+ I a still mulling over the entry I wrote about bi-vocational pastors. The conversation about the article on Facebook fleshed out all sort of auxiliary issues, such as training/seminary, mobility, theology of ordination etc. I am sure these come up again in future writing.
+Closely related to issues of vocation is my desire to see rostering of deacons/diaconal ministers be something that happens at the synodical level, not at the national level. Training need not require a seminary degree, but training needs to be local and contextual. I know the Florida-Bahamas synod already has something in place like this, but I would like to see it church wide.
+ Things at church seem to be pretty well at church right no. Of course there are always a couple of naysayers in the group determined to bring everyone else down.
+ Sent off a coupe of large sections of my thesis yesterday and I am hoping to get some good feedback.